The SEO Elite Circle

Verdict

By Editorial team. Opinion within the published method; every figure is from the record below.

The SEO Elite Circle is a private Skool community run by Julian Goldie, priced at $149 a month on the Skool storefront, with 704 members and weekly live calls. The directory lists it but does not rank it: evidence is tier C, confidence is low, and there is no course-level public rating anywhere we checked. Transparency is the weak spot. No published refund policy, no lesson list or module count, and the seller's own site shows a different monthly and annual price than the storefront. It suits senior operators who want direct access to an instructor and a link-partner pool. Beginners wanting a structured AI search curriculum should look elsewhere.

Score breakdown

Composite 60.0 of 100, rubric v1, evidence tier C, low confidence (38 of 67 attributes confirmed, checked 18 Sep 2026). The score measures public evidence about a program (what is published, what learners say, how current it is), not teaching quality.

AI SEO course scoring methodology: weights, evidence ladder, confidence rule and what was checked and not found for every program. Every price in context: AI SEO course cost.

Weight redistribution (evidence ladder): satisfaction (22%) to sentiment, transparency.

Third-party assessments

Audit scores published by one reviewer. Rendered for reference with source and date; never an input to the composite.

Facts

Each value carries its data label (provider-stated, observed, calculated), the date it was checked and its source. Unverified means the value could not be confirmed on a public page by the check date.

The SEO Elite Circle price and price history

Current price $149 a month (checked 18 September 2026). One dated observation on record, so no trend is shown. $149/month on the Skool storefront.

The SEO Elite Circle refund policy

No refund policy was found on a public page ().

What The SEO Elite Circle teaches

3 of 13 tracked curriculum flags are confirmed on public pages, 0 confirmed absent and 10 unverified (checked 18 September 2026). A confirmed flag means the provider's own curriculum or listing names the topic; the source is cited, the wording is not reproduced.

Reception

Ratings by platform

No course-level rating was found (checked 18 September 2026). Platforms checked: Skool, Trustpilot, G2, Reddit, youtube rating, independent review sites. A missing rating is never scored as zero; see the score breakdown for how the weight moved.

What public discussion says

Derived from 3 independent public items (reviews and forum or social posts; 1 provider-authored item excluded), labelled by theme and stance, checked 18 September 2026. No review text is stored. Stances: 1 positive, 1 mixed, 1 neutral, 0 negative.

Commentary praises live calls, instructor access and practical resources while questioning content depth and conversion evidence.

Independent discussion on record

• ippei.com (2026-06-02, mixed): An independent review describes weekly calls but questions conversion evidence and the depth of self-paced materials. seen 18 Sep 2026
• ippei.com (2026-03-29, mixed): An agency-course roundup lists coaching, SOPs and community support alongside limited self-paced material and unproven conversion impact. seen 18 Sep 2026
• charlesfloate.com (2026-08-27, mixed): A competitor comparison scores the Circle 70/100 and lists weekly hot-seat calls, DM access, SOPs and case studies. seen 18 Sep 2026

Cautions

Sourced facts from the caution checks (price consistency, page history, instructor identity, testimonial dating, self-ranking, certificate claims). Neutral by design: each line is what a public page shows, with its date.

1. The Skool storefront lists $149/month. Check 1, seen 18 Sep 2026 [2]
2. The seller-owned services page lists $97/month and $997/year. Check 1, seen 18 Sep 2026 [7]
3. The current listing title is The SEO Elite Circle and its Skool slug is seo-mastermind-2356. Check 2, seen 18 Sep 2026 [2]
4. Julian Goldie is named on the listing and has a public profile site. Check 3, seen 18 Sep 2026 [1]
5. The listing marks the community Private and advertises Instant Access. Check 4, seen 18 Sep 2026 [2]
6. Julian Goldie's Best AI SEO Course list places SEO Elite Circle at number 3. Check 6, seen 18 Sep 2026 [4]
7. An independent review page compiles program-related Reddit, YouTube and independent-site reviews and reports mixed sentiment. Check 9, seen 18 Sep 2026 [8]

Compared with

Cheaper programs in the same format band

Programs in the same format band that cost less or nothing, in composite order (checked 18 Sep 2026):

• AI Profit Boardroom: $69 a month, composite 88.1, medium confidence (18 Sep 2026)
• AI SEO Mastery: $27 a month, composite 87.6, medium confidence (18 Sep 2026)
• AI SEO: Rank Expand Academy: $99 a month, composite 86.4, medium confidence (18 Sep 2026)

The full list with prices and ratings: The SEO Elite Circle alternatives.